Download Autonomy and Intervention: Parentalism in the Caring Life by John Kultgen PDF

By John Kultgen

The fundamental dating among humans may be care, and the worrying existence is the top which people can reside. regrettably, care that isn't considerate slides into illegitimate intrusion on autonomy. Autonomy is a uncomplicated strong, and we should always no longer abridge it with out solid cause. nevertheless, it's not the one reliable. We needs to occasionally interfere within the lives of others to guard them from grave harms or supply them with vital advantages. The reflective individual, for that reason, wishes instructions for being concerned. a few modern moralists condemn paternalism categorically. This paintings examines weaknesses of their arguments and proposes new directions for paternalism, which it calls "parentalism" to prevent the patriarchal connotations of the previous time period. Its antiparentalism is extra reasonable than normal antipaternalism in response to an exaggerated recognize for autonomy. The paintings explores implications for either the private sphere of interactions among participants, corresponding to family and friends individuals, and the general public sphere of associations, laws, and the pro practices.

Show description

Read or Download Autonomy and Intervention: Parentalism in the Caring Life PDF

Similar ethics & morality books

Value and Context: the Nature of Moral and Political Knowledge

In price and Context Alan Thomas articulates and defends the view that people do own ethical and political wisdom however it is traditionally and culturally contextual wisdom in ways in which, say, mathematical or chemical wisdom isn't really. In his exposition of "cognitive contextualism" in ethics and politics he makes wide-ranging use of latest paintings in epistemology, ethical philosophy, and political concept.

Kant on Moral Autonomy

The idea that of autonomy is considered one of Kant's significant legacies for modern ethical concept. we regularly invoke autonomy as either an ethical perfect and a human correct, specifically a correct to figure out oneself independently of international determinants; certainly, to violate a person's autonomy is taken into account to be a major ethical offence.

Kuhn’s Structure of Scientific Revolutions - 50 Years On

In 1962, the book of Thomas Kuhn’s constitution ‘revolutionized’ the way in which one conducts philosophical and ancient stories of technology. during the creation of either memorable and arguable notions, similar to paradigms, clinical revolutions, and incommensurability, Kuhn argued opposed to the commonly accredited idea of medical swap as a development in the direction of the reality approximately nature, and as a substitute substituted the concept that technology is a puzzle fixing job, working below paradigms, which turn into discarded after it fails to reply for this reason to anomalous demanding situations and a rival paradigm.

Knowing the Natural Law: From Precepts and Inclinations to Deriving Oughts

Fresh discussions of Thomas Aquinas's remedy of usual legislation have targeted upon the "self-evident" personality of the 1st rules, yet few makes an attempt were made to figure out in what demeanour they're selfevident. On a few bills, a self-evident principle should have, at so much, a tenuous reference to speculative cause, in particular our wisdom of God, and it needs to be untainted via the stain of "deriving" an ought from an is.

Extra resources for Autonomy and Intervention: Parentalism in the Caring Life

Example text

2 In practice, these enterprises prove to be complementary. To analyze is to make explicit, expose to criticism, and invite defense or reform. To conceive an ideal alternative is to provide a template for determining what should be preserved and what changed. This book aspires to do something of both. To the extent that my intuitions are shaped by my culture and moral traditions, it is analytic and apologetic. To the extent that I transcend inherited prejudices on the basis of my life experience, critical thought, and the testimony of others, it is constructiveconservative in some particulars and reformist in others.

4 Moral intuitions are preanalytic cognitive-emotive responses to concrete actions, qualities of persons, and social arrangements that affect the interests of persons for whom the person with the intuitions cares and toward whom he feels obligations. Thus there is a specifically normative dimension to them, and this dimension is a function of the central role of care in human relations. An intuitive response to an action, personal quality, or social arrangement may be either identificational or normative.

This book is designed to formulate moral guidelines which the individual can Care and Morality 33 incorporate into her conscience in such a form as to allow due attention to prudence and loyalty. Moral norms take many forms, including ideals, goals, rules, and guidelines. Rules are formulas prescribing what one should do in particular situations. An ideal system or perfect code would divide all situations into exclusive categories and leave no doubt what one should do in each situation. The advantages of consensual rules are several.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.87 of 5 – based on 38 votes