Download Agent-Centered Morality: An Aristotelian Alternative to by George W. Harris PDF

By George W. Harris

What sorts of folks can we aspire to be, and the way do our aspirations healthy with our rules of rationality? In Agent-Centered Morality, George Harris argues that the majority folks aspire to a undeniable type of integrity: we want to be respectful of and sympathetic to others, and to be loving mom and dad, buddies, and individuals of our groups. opposed to a winning Kantian consensus, Harris deals an Aristotelian view of the issues awarded through useful cause, difficulties of integrating all our matters right into a coherent, significant existence in a manner that preserves our integrity. the duty of fixing those difficulties is "the integration test."Systematically addressing the paintings of significant Kantian thinkers, Harris exhibits that even the main complex modern types of the Kantian view fail to combine all the values that correspond to what we name an ethical existence. through demonstrating how the which means of lifestyles and sensible cause are internally comparable, he constructs from Aristotle's suggestion a conceptual scheme that effectively integrates the entire features that make a lifestyles significant, with out jeopardizing where of any. Harris's elucidation of this strategy is an enormous contribution to debates on human corporation, useful cause, and morality.

Show description

Read or Download Agent-Centered Morality: An Aristotelian Alternative to Kantian Internalism PDF

Best ethics & morality books

Value and Context: the Nature of Moral and Political Knowledge

In worth and Context Alan Thomas articulates and defends the view that people do own ethical and political wisdom however it is traditionally and culturally contextual wisdom in ways in which, say, mathematical or chemical wisdom isn't really. In his exposition of "cognitive contextualism" in ethics and politics he makes wide-ranging use of up to date paintings in epistemology, ethical philosophy, and political conception.

Kant on Moral Autonomy

The concept that of autonomy is one among Kant's relevant legacies for modern ethical suggestion. we regularly invoke autonomy as either an ethical perfect and a human correct, in particular a correct to figure out oneself independently of overseas determinants; certainly, to violate a person's autonomy is taken into account to be a significant ethical offence.

Kuhn’s Structure of Scientific Revolutions - 50 Years On

In 1962, the ebook of Thomas Kuhn’s constitution ‘revolutionized’ the way in which one conducts philosophical and ancient reports of technological know-how. in the course of the creation of either memorable and arguable notions, corresponding to paradigms, medical revolutions, and incommensurability, Kuhn argued opposed to the normally authorised concept of medical switch as a development in the direction of the reality approximately nature, and as a substitute substituted the concept technological know-how is a puzzle fixing task, working lower than paradigms, which turn into discarded after it fails to reply hence to anomalous demanding situations and a rival paradigm.

Knowing the Natural Law: From Precepts and Inclinations to Deriving Oughts

Contemporary discussions of Thomas Aquinas's remedy of average legislations have targeted upon the "self-evident" personality of the 1st rules, yet few makes an attempt were made to figure out in what demeanour they're selfevident. On a few debts, a self-evident principle should have, at such a lot, a tenuous reference to speculative cause, particularly our wisdom of God, and it has to be untainted through the stain of "deriving" an ought from an is.

Extra info for Agent-Centered Morality: An Aristotelian Alternative to Kantian Internalism

Example text

Necessarily, P ought to do x. 2. Necessarily, if P ought to do x, P can do x. 3. Therefore, P can do x. It is the fact that the first premise is necessarily true on the Kantian view that prevents its falsification by showing that the consequent of (2) is false. This argument can then be employed to show that reason motivates by add[9] . Korsgaard, "Skepticism about Practical Reason," 23 n. 17. , 23. [11] . See Immanuel Kant, Critique of Practical Reason , trans. Lewis White Beck (Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill, 1956), 5:30–31; Marcia Baron, Kantian Ethics Almost Without Apology (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1995), 44–45; Allison, Kant's Theory of Freedom , 230–49.

Reflective equilibrium is gained when the original position has been set up in a way that not only allows a choice of principles that are rational from that position but also where the results of the choice model yield maximal coherence be[15] . John Rawls, Political Liberalism (New York: Columbia University Press, 1993), 89–130. [16] John Harsanyi, "Morality and the Theory of Rational Behavior," in Utilitarianism and Beyond , ed. Amartya Sen and Bernard Williams (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982), 39–62.

Therefore, for any practical claim, R, that P do x, R gives P a reason to do x only if P has a desire to do x or x is a means to satisfying some of P's desires. Korsgaard wants to assert that since the second premise is necessary to get to the conclusion, which constitutes the denial that reason alone can motivate, it is not the internalism requirement itself that leads to skepticism of pure practical reason. From this, she wants to assert that Williams's insistence on internalism itself does no work against Kant.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.92 of 5 – based on 10 votes